How a tardigrade senses its world
An animal that moves has to know something about where it is. Here are seven ways a small animal could do that, what each one would mean, and what is actually known about it in a tardigrade. Four of the seven are blank. They are on this page anyway, because a page that lists only the answered ones would tell you the field is further along than it is.
Counts below are claims in the project graph, each carrying a source and a page number. They describe what we have read, not what exists β the difference matters and is spelled out at the foot of every empty section.
Light
Photoreception β seeing, or at least telling light from
dark and which way it comes from.
63claims
16 open
best mapped This is the only sense in a tardigrade with real anatomy behind it. Each animal has two pigment-cup eyes of about 90 Β΅mΒ³, buried inside the outer lobes of the brain. Four cells make each one, and none of them carries an axon β five separate neurons alongside carry the signal out.
The genetics are richer than the anatomy. The animal carries at least 107 opsin genes β the light-catching proteins β and the authors say that is a lower bound. One of them, neuropsin, turns up in the midgut and storage cells, tissues with no known connection to vision.
Watch a signal go in
Light enters the cup, the rhabdomeric cell responds, and the five axon-bearing neurons carry it forward. Then the animation stops, because that is where the evidence stops.
The signal stops where the evidence stops. Four cells detect, five neurons carry, and the destination in the brain has never been followed. Everything before the dashed line is from a serial reconstruction; everything after it is unknown. Brightness changes how hard the rhabdomeric cell responds β which is itself an assumption, since nobody has recorded from one.
Touch
Mechanoreception β feeling contact, texture, vibration,
or the pull of its own body.
17claims
2 open
presumed Tardigrades carry structures everybody calls sense organs: cirri and clavae on the heads of heterotardigrades, sensory fields and papillae on eutardigrades. They are innervated β individual nerves have been traced to individual appendages β and that innervation is the whole basis for calling them sensory.
Only 3 of the 17 claims are about the laboratory animal. The rest are Echiniscus testudo, Actinarctus doryphorus and Milnesium, and which structure corresponds to which across those groups is actively disputed in our graph.
Chemistry
Chemoreception β detecting substances in the water
around it. In us this splits into smell and taste.
12claims
1 open
borrowed A tardigrade finds food, and most tardigrades find a mate, so something must be detecting chemistry. One of our twelve claims is about a tardigrade at all; the rest are velvet worms and other animals, kept for comparison.
The clavae β club-shaped head appendages of heterotardigrades β are the usual suspects, on the grounds of their shape and their nerve supply. That is an argument from anatomy, not an observation of the animal responding to anything.
Water
Hygroreception β sensing that the water is going away.
This is the one that should exist.
0claims
0 open
nothing A tardigrade's famous trick is surviving being dried out. To do it, it has to start in time: pull in its legs, fold into a tun, and make the protective proteins before the water has gone. That is a response, and a response needs a detector.
We hold 71 claims about desiccation and anhydrobiosis. Exactly three of them use the words sense, detect, trigger or cue, and none of those describes a receptor, a gene or a cell that measures water. The most famous ability of this animal, and the thing that tells it to start is unrecorded.
Temperature
Thermoreception β telling hot from cold.
0claims
0 open
nothing Tardigrades survive from near absolute zero to above boiling in the dried state, and their development rate changes measurably with temperature in the wet one. Whether the animal detects temperature, as opposed to merely being affected by it, is not addressed by anything we hold.
Its own body
Proprioception β knowing where its legs are without
looking.
0claims
2 open
nothing measured A tardigrade walks with eight legs in a coordinated gait, and switches gait with speed. Coordination of that kind usually needs feedback from the limbs. We hold no claims about stretch receptors or any proprioceptive organ in a tardigrade β but we do hold two open questions, both asked about other animals, which is a small clue about where to look.
Magnetism
Magnetoreception β sensing the Earth's field, as some
migrating animals do.
0claims
0 open
nothing Included because it is the kind of thing people ask about tardigrades, and because leaving it off would imply it had been ruled out. It has not been ruled out and it has not been looked for. We hold nothing.
Why the blanks are on the page
Three of these seven senses have real material behind them and four have none. A page that showed only the three would be the more impressive page, and it would give a false picture of a field that is small, young, and mostly working on one animal.
There is also a practical reason. Every blank above is something a person could do. The phototaxis assay is a lamp, a dish and an afternoon. The needle test wants repeating with a modern microscope. Hygroreception wants somebody to film a tardigrade drying and watch what moves first. None of these need a grant.