Tardigraph

What would a tardigrade need to live somewhere else?

Almost everything written about tardigrades and space is about what they can survive. Survival, for this animal, means being dried out and switched off. That is not living anywhere — it is the opposite of it. So ask the harder question instead: what would it take for one to be awake, eating and laying eggs somewhere that is not Earth? The list turns out to be shorter than it first looks, and the last step is the interesting one.

Being switched off is not living there

Every famous number — the vacuum, the radiation, the cold near absolute zero — is measured on a tun: the animal folded up, dried, metabolism at or near a standstill. Keilin's 1959 definition is a state with no visible signs of life.

A dried tardigrade on Mars is cargo, not a resident. To count as living somewhere it has to come back, and to stay back it needs three things.

liquid wateroxygenfood

Liquid water, and not a little

This one is not negotiable and it is not the dramatic one. Hypsibius exemplaris is aquatic: it lives in a film of water in moss, or in water outright, and it is kept in the laboratory in a few millilitres of spring water. Dry it out and it stops being an inhabitant and becomes cargo again.

Standard culture: 150 mL of Chalkley's medium plus soil extract in a flask, or 15 mL of spring water in a 6 cm dish, with the water changed every 10 days to 6 weeks. Cold Spring Harbor protocol, 2018, p. 868 · H. exemplaris

Oxygen, and it is fussier about this than about radiation

A tardigrade has no lungs, no gills and no blood. Gas moves across the cuticle by diffusion into a fluid-filled body cavity. That works beautifully at a quarter of a millimetre long, and it means the animal is at the mercy of the oxygen immediately around it.

Active adult H. exemplaris held below 1 ppm oxygen (measured 0.2–0.75 ppm) at 20–22 °C recovered well after short exposures, but almost none survived long ones. Hagelbäck & Jönsson 2023 — full text read · H. exemplaris, Richtersius cf. coronifer

Worth pausing on: the animal that shrugs off hard vacuum when dried is killed by a day of low oxygen when awake. The famous tolerances and the living requirements are two different lists, and only the second one decides where it could live.

Food — and here the list starts to collapse

In the laboratory it eats a green alga. Not Chlorella, which is the one people usually name: the stock strain is maintained on Chlorococcum, chosen for ease of culture and strain stability, though the animal grows on diverse algae.

H. exemplaris grows on diverse algae, but the stock has been maintained on Chlorococcum spp. for ease of culture and strain stability. Cold Spring Harbor protocol, 2018 · H. exemplaris

So now the question looks worse, not better. We have never found Chlorococcum on another world, and looking for a specific green alga on an exoplanet is not a research programme.

Except that the alga is a plant.

The alga makes the oxygen

Chlorococcum photosynthesises. Give it light, carbon dioxide and water and it produces oxygen and more of itself. The tardigrade eats it, breathes the oxygen it made, and breathes out the carbon dioxide the alga needs.

So oxygen is not an input to the system. It is something the system makes. Cross it off, and cross off food with it, because food is what the light and the carbon dioxide turn into.

liquid wateroxygenfood carbon dioxidelight

Three requirements became three again — but they are completely different three. Water, CO₂ and light are the commonest things in the universe worth naming. That is a question you can actually take to a catalogue of planets.

The loop

What you have at that point is not a list of supplies. It is a cycle, with two organisms each producing what the other consumes, driven by light from outside.

liquid water, all of it, all the time alga Chlorococcum tardigrade H. exemplaris O₂ + biomass CO₂ light

Two organisms and a light source. Nothing enters but light; nothing has to be resupplied but what leaks. This is the smallest arrangement in which a tardigrade is living somewhere rather than being stored there.

What we have not shown. Nobody, as far as our reading goes, has actually run this loop closed — a tardigrade and its alga sealed together, balanced, for any length of time. The culture protocols all assume an open flask on a bench in air, with the water changed every few weeks. The collapse from five requirements to three is an inference from what each organism does, and it is recorded in our graph as an inference rather than an observation. It is also a testable one, and the equipment is a sealed dish.

This is the point where the question splits, and both directions are real.

Where is there liquid water? If the requirement is water, CO₂ and light, then the question becomes astronomy. The Kepler Atlas maps the planets the Kepler telescope found, with habitable-zone estimates from the Kopparapu climate model and its limits written down. Take the three requirements there and see what is left. Or: how wide is the range it can do this in? Temperature, pressure, radiation, oxygen — the conditions under which a tardigrade stays awake rather than merely intact. Including which of the famous numbers we have actually read the paper for, and which we have not.

How this page was built

Every step above is a claim in the project graph with a source and a page number, except the collapse in step 5, which is an inference joining two of them. The oxygen sensitivity comes from a paper we read in full; the culture and diet from the published protocol; the definition of cryptobiosis from Keilin via a 2018 review.

The things this page does not use are the famous ones. The space-exposure result and the 600 MPa pressure figure are both in our graph marked not read — the papers are paywalled or blocked and are on our fetch list. They would not change the argument, because they are about survival while switched off, and this page is about being awake.

How a tardigrade senses its world Seven ways it could, four of them blank — including how it detects that it is drying out Keeping tardigrades The actual protocol: what the water is, what the algae are, how often it is changed